Medxcode medical billing and coding

Are Your Paid Claims Underpaid? A Medical Billing Audit Guide

Audit paid claims, adjustments, and deposits to separate recoverable underpayments from valid reductions—and measure revenue only when additional cash arrives.

November 18, 2026 · 4 min read

1. Start with a revenue question, not a recovery promise

For your next medical billing audit, ask: Did our practice receive the correct payment for services already marked paid? Make the objective a documented reconciliation of expected reimbursement, adjudicated payment, and actual receipts—not a list of differences between charges and payments.

CMS explains that an electronic remittance advice (ERA) describes payment adjustments involving contracts, secondary payers, coverage, and patient cost sharing. A payment below the billed charge therefore needs investigation, not an automatic underpayment label. (cms.gov)

As a practical starting scope, choose one payer, a defined service-date window, and several frequently billed services. Include paid claims with unusually large adjustments and a comparison group without obvious exceptions. Treat this as a targeted operational review; do not present its findings as a statistically representative estimate of losses across the practice.

    2. Build a claim-level evidence file

    Before engaging an auditor, specify the records and deliverables. For each sampled service line, request the submitted claim, relevant documentation, ERA, account ledger, payment record, and applicable contract or reimbursement policy. Record which policy version applied to the date of service.

    CMS distinguishes the EFT, which transfers funds, from the ERA, which explains payment. It also describes matching trace information to associate a deposit with its remittance. Use that distinction to test both adjudication and cash posting rather than assuming either proves the other. (cms.gov)

    Require the auditor to show the expected-payment calculation. Keep billed charges, allowed amounts, payer liability, and patient responsibility in separate fields. Where the governing contract or policy is unavailable, label the finding unverified rather than recoverable.

    • Capture claim identifier, service date, payer product, procedure, modifiers, units, rendering provider, and place of service.
    • Attach supporting evidence, the proposed correction, the responsible staff member, and the verified submission or appeal deadline.

    3. Separate underpayments from posting and adjustment issues

    Review the adjustment group code, Claim Adjustment Reason Code, and Remittance Advice Remark Code together. CMS describes these as complementary explanations of claim-level and service-line adjustments. Use them to frame the investigation, then check the actual contract and policy before deciding whether to challenge payment. (cms.gov)

    Check provider-level adjustments separately. CMS notes that Provider Level Balance adjustments can include interest or deductions for prior overpayments and usually are not tied to a specific claim on that remittance. Reconcile these before calling a deposit difference a claim underpayment. (cms.gov)

    Do not transfer disputed balances to patients merely to close accounts. For Medicare, CMS identifies CO as provider responsibility and says beneficiaries may be billed only when an adjustment uses PR. A suspected payer shortfall is not, by itself, authorization to bill the patient. (cms.gov)

    • Classify findings as validated payer underpayments, posting errors, valid reductions, documentation or coding concerns, or unresolved exceptions.
    • Route potential overpayments to a separate compliance review rather than netting them against hoped-for recoveries.

    4. Turn each validated finding into an accountable correction

    For every actionable finding, assign an owner and select the appropriate payer-specific route: corrected claim, reconsideration, appeal, or payment-posting correction. Require staff to verify the applicable deadline and supporting-document requirements before submission.

    Keep coding changes separate from payment disputes. Ask a qualified reviewer to assess the existing clinical record before recommending a different code or modifier. Escalate uncertain medical-necessity questions to an appropriate clinician.

    This workflow is an operational recommendation, not a universal legal audit mandate. HHS OIG expressly describes its General Compliance Program Guidance as voluntary and nonbinding. Applicable laws, program requirements, and payer contracts still need separate evaluation; an audit report is not a compliance certification. (oig.hhs.gov)

      5. Measure collected revenue—not just identified opportunity

      Ask for a closeout report that separates suspected discrepancies, validated underpayments, submitted corrections, and additional cash actually received. Keep posting-only corrections separate from new receipts. For an internal return-on-investment calculation, subtract audit and rework costs from incremental collections attributable to the review.

      Schedule a follow-up sample after corrective changes. Check whether the same adjustment pattern recurs, whether payment rules were updated correctly, and whether staff can reproduce the expected-payment calculation. Set the cadence around your practice’s risks and workload.

      Before purchasing a Medical Billing Audit, require a written scope covering payer selection, documentation review, recovery support, exclusions, and pricing. Medxcode service fees start at 2.99%, with no hidden fees; confirm the audit-specific scope and fee basis. Contact info@medxcode.com to discuss your practice’s review. Findings do not guarantee additional payment.

        Related Medxcode services

        Sources

        AI-assisted research. Confirm applicable payer policies and effective dates before changing billing procedures.

        Related service

        Medical Billing Audit

        Compliance, coding and revenue-leakage review with a fix plan.

        See how medical billing audit works →